’60 Minutes’ Gets Its First Report Cards — But Will Partisan Critics on Both Sides Judge it Fairly?
You are reading a special free preview of Mediaite’s daily newsletter — the Mediaite One Sheet: a fast, five-minute briefing that curates the best of the media newsletters. Subscribe today at a special new (lower) price to get the One Sheet delivered direct to your inbox five days a week!
TOP STORY
’60 MINUTES’ GETS ITS FIRST REPORT CARDS
The first episode of Bari Weiss and Nick Bilton’s 60 Minutes aired Sunday, and for a lot of people, despite the turnover the show’s experienced, the actual episode seemed to be more of the same — exactly what they expected. But for some of our authors, it’s just too soon to determine what the heck is actually going to unfold for the program this season.
That’s partly because some members of the conservative-leaning media will be looking for any chance to call the reimagined show a success from the jump, and partly because their more liberal counterparts have already written it off.
THREE TAKES
Barrett Media’s Morning Edition, Garrett Searight — It’s too soon to claim Bari Weiss’ first stab at 60 Minutes was a success, Searight wrote today. Searight believes conservative media will call the race before it’s even really begun. “Conservative media figures across radio, television, podcasts, and social media will call it a win [if it gets a big rating],” Searight continued. “That’s poppycock. Mularkey. Balderdash. Pick your favorite synonym for ‘b*llshit’, because that’s what a one-episode victory lap amounts to.” The show may still end up a success, but “nobody watching a single Sunday broadcast can prove that’s what’s happening, and pretending otherwise does a disservice to how ratings actually work.”
Newsbusters, Nicholas Spinnato — But counter to what Barrett’s Searight believes, one conservative outlet DID NOT jump to praise the new 60 Minutes. Despite plenty of concern from the Left that a Weiss-run 60 Minutes would offer little more than Trumpian propaganda, for Spinnato, Sunday’s episode “continued to showcase the program’s liberal bias.” Ahead of the season premiere, a Newsbusters study determined the “show had a nearly five-to-one bias of liberal stories compared to conservative ones over the past six seasons.” As Spinnato concluded, “In reality, the season premiere did not feel that much different compared to the previous seasons, as the show led with two familiar faces in correspondents Norah O’Donnell and Lesley Stahl, and the pair, especially Stahl, still showed their anti-Trump bias.”
Status, Oliver Darcy — The episode relied on an exclusive from an American service member identified only as “Bravo” — and how the show obtained that conversation, as well as interviews with Joint Chiefs of Staff, Gen. Dan Caine, and Secretary of Defense Pete Hegseth, is of note, Darcy insisted. Sources told Darcy that “Weiss personally secured the interview with the help of Hegseth’s wife, Jennifer, a former Fox News producer who has become a de facto Pentagon adviser.” As one person put it, the two are so close that Weiss can simply pick up the phone and call Jennifer. Despite that, the Trump White House was apparently still “unsure” about how CBS would handle the segment because “the piece could backfire and remind Americans about a deeply unpopular war.”
TAKEAWAY: What’s interesting about the early assessment from partisan critics of 60 Minutes is that both sides seem to have incredibly high or low expectations. It almost feels like the Left-leaning newsletters believe 60 Minutes is going to resemble Pravda, while the Right-leaning newsletters are expecting a stream of hard-hitting stories about Democrats. Assuming neither side is correct in their assessment of how it will play out, will they give a fair hearing to what 60 Minutes actually becomes, or will they just play to the script that they have seemingly already written? Much has been made about how 60 Minutes will be a barometer for CBS News as a whole — and that is true. But the evaluations of 60 Minutes will be a barometer for the newsletter critics as well. Are they capable of casting aside preconceived notions and giving the show a fair evaluation on the merits?
TOP SCOOPS & ANALYSIS 
SCOOP
CJR’s The Media Today, Ivan L. Nagy —Russia is set to hold the country’s first parliamentary election since launching its 2022 invasion of Ukraine this weekend, and “the stakes are low” for President Vladimir Putin since “the country’s sole pro-peace party was banned from running for seats in a chamber that holds no effective power anyway.” But the moment is still an “uncomfortable” one Putin, because Russians are once again paying attention to war coverage. As Mediazona editor Alexander Borodikhin told Nagy, a lot of that coverage is culled from “social media posts and eyewitness accounts from gas stations” and he and the magazine’s team have “scraped publicly available data, including bank registries of gas station transactions, to create a map that tracked the availability of fuel” to get to the truth. Roman Anin, the founder of the similarly “exciled” iStories, also told Nagy, “We still work with reporters inside Russia, but I can’t disclose any details about our cooperation for security reasons—these journalists risk their freedom to do their work.”
SCOOP
POLITICO Playbook, Will Steakin, Dasha Burns, Adam Wren — Gavin Newsom said he won’t run for president if Kamala Harris opts to launch a campaign in 2028, but some aren’t so sure, Playbook wrote today. Mark Buell, former finance chair for Harris and a donor to both, said, “I don’t believe it.” Elsewhere, Rahm Emanuel had something to say about Newsom’s recent fly fishing segment with CNN’s Jake Tapper. “While Gavin and I both enjoy fly fishing this is what the joy looks like. Also, if you are talking while fishing, you let the big ones get away and you’re likely to say something big,” he texted Playbook.
ANALYSIS
Awful Announcing’s The A Block — ESPN’s College Gameday was talk of the virtual town yesterday after Sen. Ted Cruz (R-TX) paid a pretty disastrous appearance to the program over the weekend, and now The A Block is asking a pertinent question: what exactly does the show want to be, anyway? “For three decades, the show operated on a simple, almost monastic premise: put smart people in front of a rowdy campus crowd and let them talk football for three hours,” The A Block noted today. Unfortunately for viewers who enjoyed the format, “That show no longer exists in its original form, and pretending otherwise is an act of willful denial.” Now they’re met with “a hybrid organism — part sports program, part variety hour, part corporate mouthpiece — stitched together by whichever storyline generates the most engagement that week” and “none of this is accidental.”
ANALYSIS
The Free Press, Amanda Knox and Jed Rubenfeld — The Press offered two takes on Patrick Clancy, ex-husband of Massachusetts mom Lindsay Clancy, who was on trial this month to determine if she should be held criminally responsible for killing the pair’s three children Cora, Dawson, and Callan. First, Amanda Knox (who was arrested and tried in Italy in 2017 for the murder of her then-roommate) insisted Patrick “can’t win” no matter what is decided. After Patrick ran a marathon in memory of his children in April 2024, “strangers cheered his name along the course,” she noted. “But two years later, the internet, which spent this summer obsessively watching the trial for his children’s murders, dug up the footage and turned against him.” Jed Rubenfeld also took those who have accused Patrick of committing Lindsay’s horrific crimes to task. While Patrick may be able to sue those who have defamed him, he “can’t stop the tide because it is driven by two phenomena that are basically untouchable.”
ANALYSIS
The Washington Sun, Evan McMorris-Santoro, Jasmine Wright, and Manuela Silva — Congress has “scrambled to respond to the wild AI news cycle”’ this week, but is doing so “while at the same time moving ahead with plans to raise billions from investors to build more advanced stuff that could also annihilate civilization while at the same time moving ahead with plans to raise billions from investors to build more advanced stuff that could also annihilate civilization.” In the short term, it doesn’t seem the Trump administration will be doing much to ease the fears of those worried about AI. It’s also true that “Democrats also haven’t decided how scared they should be.”
BUSINESS OF MEDIA 
Simon Owens’s Media Newsletter, Simon Owens — Atlantic CEO Nicholas Thompson revealed that while overall search traffic from Google has declined, the number of digital subscribers converting directly from Google links has actually gone up! Owens isn’t really shocked, but it’s an interesting observation, anyway. QUOTE
“That makes intuitive sense. Low-intent users are often satisfied with a simple answer from a chatbot. The people who click through to the source are more likely to be genuinely interested in the subject and want to go deeper. And the more interested someone is in a topic, the more likely they are to pay for access to additional information.”
The Publisher Newsletter, Peter Houston — 104-year-old Hearst UK’s Good Housekeeping achieved its highest revenue ever in 2025 alongside double-digit growth in digital and print advertising. Managing Director Liz Settle highlighted that consumer trust in magazine brands is rising as trust in social media platforms erodes, with AI search tools actively directing readers toward verified publishers. QUOTE
“Central to Settle’s excitement for the future of magazines is Hearst’s own data that shows trust in magazine brands is rising at the same time it is ‘dropping off a cliff’ for social media platforms.”
The Ankler’s The Wakeup, Sean McNulty — A little studio business: Paramount and Netflix have concluded their output partnership with Skydance Animation after producing four feature films. Skydance’s fifth animated feature, John Lasseter’s Cosmic Motors, is shifting to Paramount for a theatrical release next year as Netflix expands its animation slate with Sony Animation. QUOTE
“Well, at least this relatively brief relationship is going out on a high note with Swapped…”
Simon Owens’s Media Newsletter, Simon Owens — Google is testing a Search Console-based licensing initiative that pays select news publishers when their content contributes significantly to Gemini and AI Overviews responses. Industry critics contend the pay-per-value model operates primarily as a legal shield while leaving independent creators shut out from payouts. QUOTE
“But as always with news like this, my first question is: Which publishers will actually get paid? I can see from my own analytics that all the major LLMs are crawling my newsletter, yet as an independent publisher, I have little hope that Google or any other AI company will cut me a check anytime soon.”
ADWEEK Daily, Brittaney Kiefer — Audio hardware brand Sonos is launching a new creative campaign under chief marketing officer Colleen DeCourcy. It’s aimed at restoring consumer trust, which seems to be a theme of today’s stack, no? The brand push follows a controversial 2024 app update that damaged consumer perception. QUOTE
“It also articulates for the first time that Sonos is not just a speaker company but an end-to-end sound system.”
The Poynter Report, Tom Jones — Newsletter business! The Poynter Institute presented its “Make a Mark” leadership award to Bulwark publisher Sarah Longwell and Atlantic CEO Nicholas Thompson. The award recognizes media leaders who produce journalism that is both financially sustainable and highly relevant to modern audiences.
OTHER COOL STUFF
POLITICO Playbook — Vice President JD Vance offered an unexpected television critique, calling Emily in Paris a “masterwork of American television” and “the Shakespeare of our time,” framing the show as a “massive cultural criticism of millennial decision-making.”
The Ankler’s The Wakeup — Oprah Winfrey is set to host a three-day immersive live show called Oprah Winfrey’s AHA at the Las Vegas Sphere in April, featuring performances by musician Jacob Collier and poet Ocean Vuong.
WHAT GOT MISSED? 
POLITICO Playbook, Will Steakin, Dasha Burns, Adam Wren — Trump will “headline a big-ticket RNC fundraiser in Manhattan on Monday, Sept. 21,” Playbook revealed today, citing an invitation they received. “The get-in price for the “intimate reception & photo opportunity” is set at $150,000 per couple.” For all the anonymous grousing from Republicans about Trump not helping their cause in the midterms, it feels like this story should’ve gotten a bit more attention.
NEWSLETTER OF THE DAY 
POLITICO Playbook, Will Steakin, Dasha Burns, Adam Wren — Playbook led things by announcing their new newsletter editor Kyler Alvord, so today’s Newsletter of the Day is a very newsletter-y pick indeed. Alvord joined Playbook by way of People, where he worked as the lead politics editor. Playbook also devoted significant space to all things AI, very much proving Steakin, Burns, and Wren constantly have their collective finger on the pulse of what Americans are paying attention to, even when the government is trying to distract.
This newsletter was produced by Lindsey Ellefson.
The post ’60 Minutes’ Gets Its First Report Cards — But Will Partisan Critics on Both Sides Judge it Fairly? first appeared on Mediaite.
from Mediaite https://ift.tt/2wERt9G




